6 Steps to Winning Arguments

As business owners, we all deal with arguments: a client who wants a refund months after your clearly stated return/refund policy dates have passed; a vendor who won’t budge on terms; a team member who sees a project differently than you do. Broadcast journalist Mehdi Hasan built a career on the arts of persuasion and public speaking, and his book Win Every Argument breaks down the moves to winning debates. Inspired by his ideas, I have created a framework to manage disagreements that may arise in your day-to-day business.

Before You Speak

1. Know the context. If you’re having a disagreement with an employee, customer, or vendor, familiarize yourself with the context. Research the relationship history and make an effort to see both sides well enough to anticipate the pushback coming before it arrives. Preparation is what makes a calm response possible. If an argument arises and you are not familiar with the context in the moment, ask for a time to review the background and schedule a time to continue the conversation. Not only will you be prepared, the time-out may work in your favor.

While You’re Making Your Case

2. Use concrete examples. If you have encountered the same issue in the past, tell the story of what happened as you explain your position. A real example of what you did in the past, why you did it, and whether the outcome was positive or negative, carries more weight in an argument than a hypothetical scenario. If the issue is new to you, use specific, fact-based reasons—not your gut feelings—to build your case. 

3. Demonstrate empathy. Connect your position to what the other person actually cares about — their time, their bottom line, their team. 

4. Stay calm intentionally. A calm tone builds credibility, especially when the conversation gets tense. Staying composed signals confidence and primes you to practice active listening. Take a deep breath and a long exhale to slow your reaction.

Closing the Disagreement

5. Reference their own words. Bringing back something they said earlier again demonstrates active listening, and it places your position within the context of language they previously agreed with.

6. End on one clear point. People remember the last thing. Give them a single, memorable takeaway or next step to walk away with.

Although I called this a framework for winning arguments, a business argument isn’t the Super Bowl. In business disagreements, your goal is not to win at any cost. Ideally, both parties leave the room in agreement and with a sense of fair play.

If you would like to discuss strategies for your business growth and success, let’s talk:

Schedule Meeting